AAAI

Archives



2009 conference
2008 conference
2007 conference


Subscribe






This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?

Blog

Home

Venue

Call for Papers

Schedule

Tutorials

Registration

Hotel Info

Important Dates

Submission

Accepted Papers

Invited Speakers

Program Committee

Data Challenge

Sponsors

ICWSM 2009

ICWSM 2008

ICWSM 2007

Past proceedings

Videolectures from 2008

Videolectures from 2009

4th Int'l AAAI Conference on Weblogs and Social Media

May 23-26, 2010, George Washington University, Washington, DC

Sponsored by the Association for the Advancement of Artificial Intelligence.


ICWSM 2010 Blog

Friday, March 5, 2010

 

Response to Ed Chi about the review process

In a comment to a previous post Ed Chi asked:

Can you give some transparency to how decisions are made to reduce a full paper to a poster / short paper?
In answer - the review process this year was somewhat different from previous years:

- For each paper, one SPC-member meta-reviewer and three PC-member reviewers were assigned, primarily based on bidding, with some manual balancing of the reviewers by the PC chairs (in part based on requests from the SPC).

- The PC members submitted reviews independently (i.e., without seeing the other reviews)

- The SPC member then led a discussion of the paper, in the case of any substantive disagreement, and wrote a fourth review summarizing the results. Sometimes extra reviews were asked for at this point. The discussion is not available to the authors, although the SPC members were encouraged to summarize it in the meta-review.

At this point, if everyone's done their job - there's a lot of information about each paper, but all the decisions were based on a very local view of the pool of submissions (as each reviewer sees only 8-10 papers), and reviewers tend to calibrate their scores differently in different sub-areas. In the final stage, a small group - Sam and I, with some help from Marti and previous ICWSM organizers - looked over all the papers, reading the reviews for many of them, the meta-reviews for all of them, and sometimes the papers themselves - to give a final ranking. Aside from the raw scores for the paper, we considered the overall topical balance of the conference, and the perceived breadth of interest in a paper, but these were secondary considerations. This discussion is also not provided to the authors.

BTW, my comment about this year having a strong pool of submissions wasn't polite conversation. There were a half-dozen papers with an average score of 8.5 or above, 16 papers with an average score of 8 or above, and 30 with an average score of 7 or above. After looking the papers over one of our first steps was to figure out what was the maximal amount of papers we could present as plenaries (25), given the time constraints of the conference, and we spent a lot of time discussing the papers that were close to the cut-off. We also considered but rejected the possibility of introducing parallel sessions this year.

William Cohen
co-PC chair


Comments: «Oldest ‹Older 401 – 600 of 1505 Newer› Newest»
Hey check this out helpful blog,best vegetable delivery service

 
Hey check this out helpful blog,best vegetable delivery service

 
Hey check this out helpful blog,fruit & veg boxes delivery in south london

 
Hey check this out helpful blog,fruits and vegetables home delivery

 
Hey check this out helpful blog,fruits and vegetables home delivery

 
online courses uk, Best course choice for your better future with distance learning ? study in the uk

 
distance learning courses, Best course choice for your better future with distance learning ? distance learning courses

 
online courses uk, Best course choice for your better future with distance learning ? online courses uk

 
Looking for accounting training, Best course choice for your better future with distance learning ? accounting training

 
Looking for best distance learning courses in uk for your better future ? best distance learning courses in uk

 
Looking for best distance learning courses in uk for your better future ? best distance learning courses in uk

 
distance learning courses, Best course choice for your better future with distance learning ? distance learning courses

 
online courses uk, Best course choice for your better future with distance learning ? online courses uk

 
Looking for accounting training, Best course choice for your better future with distance learning ? accounting training

 
Looking for best distance learning courses in uk for your better future ? best distance learning courses in uk

 
Looking for accounting training, Best course choice for your better future with distance learning ? accounting training

 
Hey check this out helful blog christian singles app

 
Hey check this out helful blog christian singles dating app

 
Hey check this out helful blog christian singles dating app

 
Hey check this out helful blog christian singles app

 
Hey check this out helful blog christian singles dating app

 
Hey check this out helful blog christian singles dating app

 
Hey check this out helful blog christian singles dating app

 
Hey check this out helful blog christian singles app

 
Hey check this out helful blog christian singles dating app

 
Hey check this out helful blog christian singles dating app

 
Hey check this out helful blog christian singles app

 
Hey check this out helful blog christian singles dating app

 
Hey check this out helful blog christian singles app

 
Hey check this out helful blog christian singles dating app

 
Hey check this out helful blog christian singles app

 
Hey check this out helful blog christian singles dating app

 
Hey check this out helful blog christian singles app

 
Add missing ALT text to 13 images
 
vegan moisturizer
Looking Natural and smooth skin? then you are at best place vegan moisturizer

 
organic skin care
Looking Natural and smooth skin? then you are at best place organic skin care

 
natural skin care
Looking Natural and smooth skin? then you are at best place natural skin care

 
natural skin care products
Looking Natural and smooth skin? then you are at best place natural skin care products

 
vegan skin care
Looking Natural and smooth skin? then you are at best place vegan skin care

 
natural cosmetics
Looking Natural and smooth skin? then you are at best place natural cosmetics

 
cruelty free skin care
Looking Natural and smooth skin? then you are at best place cruelty free skin care

 
vegan moisturizer
Looking Natural and smooth skin? then you are at best place vegan moisturizer

 
vegan moisturizer
Looking Natural and smooth skin? then you are at best place vegan moisturizer

 
organic skin care
Looking Natural and smooth skin? then you are at best place organic skin care

 
Hey check this out helpful blog,oddbox

 
Beauty and skincare tips Welcome to Healthandfista.com ! where we share insightful tips, tricks, and hacks on the latest fashion trends, health and wellness tips, nutrition and fitness tips, Latest news, beauty and makeup tips, SEO, budget travel…

 
check out this helpful blog onessay writing
 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat Online Liquor stores

 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat Online Liquor stores

 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat Online Liquor stores

 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat! california online liquor store

 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat! california online liquor store

 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat! buy alcohol online

 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat! buy alcohol online

 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat! cheap liquor

 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat! cheap liquor

 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat buy wine online

 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat buy wine online

 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat Online Liquor stores

 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat! california online liquor store

 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat! buy alcohol online

 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat! cheap liquor

 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat buy wine online

 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat Online Liquor stores

 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat! california online liquor store

 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat! buy alcohol online

 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat! cheap liquor

 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat buy wine online

 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat buy wine online

 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat Online Liquor stores

 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat! california online liquor store

 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat! buy alcohol online

 
Health and fitness tips


Welcome to Healthandfista.com ! where we share insightful tips, tricks, and hacks on the latest fashion trends, health and wellness tips, nutrition and fitness tips, Latest news, beauty and makeup tips, SEO, budget travel…


 
Thanks for the best blog. it was very useful for me.keep sharing such ideas in the future as well write my essay
 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat Online Liquor stores

 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat california online liquor store

 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat california online liquor store

 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat Online Liquor stores

 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat california online liquor store

 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat! cheap liquor

 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat buy wine online

 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat Online Liquor stores

 
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat! buy alcohol online

 
rent party characters Rent Party Characters bringing them to life! Hire our amazing performers for kid's parties in all of Miami Dade, Broward, and Palm Beach Fl.

 
I have a similar interest this is my page read everything carefully and let me know what you think.

토토
온라인카지노사이트
파워볼게임
바카라

 
Great blog. Your post is awesome and content is very readable I will definitely share this with my colleague!

스포츠토토
카지노사이트
파워볼
온라인카지노

 
Your information is helpful for me thanks for sharing the valuable information…

토토사이트
바카라사이트
파워볼사이트
온라인바카라

 
I found really intresting stuff here..Thank you
Virtual team building



 
I found really intresting stuff here..Thank you
Piano Lessons Singapore


 
I found really intresting stuff here..Thank you
buddhist funeral package Singapore



 
I found really intresting stuff here..Thank you
award winning wedding photographer


 
CBD oils from different plant sources often have very different ingredients - even if both oils contain the same dose of CBD. That means: Different CBD oils can affect your body in different ways.

 
CBD oils from different plant sources often have very different ingredients - even if both oils contain the same dose of CBD. That means: Different CBD oils can affect your body in different ways.

 
Hey check this out helpful blog,thanks for helping us! sustainable web design

 
I found really intresting stuff here..Thank you
award winning wedding photographer


 
I found really intresting stuff here..Thank you
buddhist funeral package Singapore


 
I found really intresting stuff here..Thank you
Piano Lessons Singapore



 
I found really intresting stuff here..Thank you
Virtual team building

 
Hey check this out helpful blog,thanks for helping us! eco web design

 
Hey check this out helpful blog,thanks for helping us! affordable seo services

 
Hey check this out helpful blog,thanks for helping us! affordable seo services uk

 
Hey check this out helpful blog,thanks for helping us! eco web design

 
Hey check this out helpful blog,thanks for helping us! eco web design

 
Hey check this out helpful blog,thanks for helping us! affordable web design services

 
Hey check this out helpful blog,thanks for helping us! affordable web design services

 
Hey check this out helpful blog,thanks for helping us! sustainable web design

 
Hey check this out helpful blog,thanks for helping us! eco web design

 
Hey check this out helpful blog,thanks for helping us! affordable seo services

 
Hey check this out helpful blog,thanks for helping us! affordable seo services uk

 
The largest, including thousands more every day With games that start every second, lovePoker is the only place that collects poker online games from many,

 
Selling cars privately can take weeks. If you don't need a used car trading, it can take months (for example, a convertible with a manual transmission was available in Detroit at the end of January). In the meantime, you have to invest in advertising and keep the car clean, as potential buyers will call at short notice to view the car.


 
This is great information! Thank you! team building cooking singapore
 
The market feasibility of population statistics and psychological statistics is studied. Usually, there is a huge demand for uesed cars for sale. Several surveys over the years have shown that people who can afford new cars are much less than those who like to buy second-hand cars.

 
Many of you may have a question, whether or not there is just football betting. But not at all,ดูบอลออนไลน์ in our sports category there are over 13 different sports to bet on, for example basketball, boxing, snooker, tennis, racing, etc

 
Hi everything) I requested a service for the first time and was happily surprised. At first I realized the ease of design and the opportunity to order a job without this long, difficult registration. In order to come here again and again, all edubirdie reviews do. I've been stealing for over a year, but it's never been so crystal clear or very easy))) I don't want to tell anyone about this place, because I fear someone else will use it. By the way, you can email each author and talk about it personally, which is really cool.
 
It was really nice to read a blog post. I have been a huge fan of your blog posts for many years. Thanks for always being there :
oxygen cylinder
oxygen concentrator price in bangladesh

 
What are the Benefits of Computer Glasses?
People wear glasses for many reasons. Many people have the problem of distinguishing faraway things or objects. Besides, many people have the problem of defining nearsighted objects. So, whenever we fail to see a faraway passerby or a car, we go to the doctor. Then the doctor prescribed us a power glass. It probably solves our problem of distinguishing objects clearly.
lentes para computadora

 
Lisanslı,Hızlı Ve Güvenilir Bahis Siteleri...!
En Hızlı Yatırım-Çekim İşlemleri.
Sitemizdeki Casino oyunları EGT lisandı ile en güvenilir casino oyunlarıdır.
Sitemiz Resmi ve Yasal Curacao lisans Sahibidir.
Casinovale Güncel Giris
En İyi Casino Sitesi
Yasal Güvenilir Casino
https://www.casinovalegiris.xyz
www.casinovale-giris.xyz
 
Global Escalators and Elevators Market size will grow from USD 88.78 Billion in 2015 to USD 125.22 Billion by 2021, at a CAGR of 6.01%. The base year considered for the study is 2015 and the market size is projected from 2016 to 2021.
 
Thank you so much for sharing an awesome piece of wonderful information with us. This is really an amazing post!!
First date tips for men to flirt with a girl
 
Powerful Black Magic Specialist is there you have a difficult you basically can't get past you can leave him in his grasp and he will deal with it. You take help of a particularly Powerful Black Magic Specialist you can trust as you are in the most secure hands on the planet. In increases, He has helped hundreds and thousands of individuals across the globe. What's more, is quite famous for his extraordinary astrology and black magic work commitments also.

He was conceived and raised in the family who had astrology and black magic work potential which is brimming with capacities in his blood. He has been rehearsing black magic from a youthful age. Also, likewise has built up an expertise for such works through his dad and progenitors. Subsequently, he is somebody whom you can trust with full confidence.

 
Accountant Bedford
Thanks for your beyond belief blogs stuff. looking for a Accountant Bedford

 
Accountant Cambridge
Thanks for your beyond belief blogs stuff. looking for a Accountant Cambridge ? Check out this!

 
Accountant Cambridgeshire
Thanks for your beyond belief blogs stuff. looking for a Accountant Cambridgeshire

 
Accountant Bedford
Thanks for your beyond belief blogs stuff. looking for a Accountant Bedford

 
Accountant Peterborough
Thanks for your beyond belief blogs stuff. looking for a Accountant Peterborough

 
Accountant Bedford
Thanks for your beyond belief blogs stuff. looking for a Accountant Bedford

 
I found really intresting stuff here..Thank you
award winning wedding photographer


 
I found really intresting stuff here..Thank you
Actual day photographer



 
I found really intresting stuff here..Thank you
portable shower and toilet


 
I found really intresting stuff here..Thank you
funeral service singapore


 
I found really intresting stuff here..Thank you
mobile toilet for rent

 
I found really intresting stuff here..Thank you
piano lessons singapore


 
I found really intresting stuff here..Thank you
piano teacher singapore

 
I found really intresting stuff here..Thank you
Virtual team building

 
study in the uk
online courses uk, Best course choice for your better future with distance learning ? study in the uk

 
study in the uk
online courses uk, Best course choice for your better future with distance learning ? study in the uk

 
distance learning courses
distance learning courses, Best course choice for your better future with distance learning ? distance learning courses

 
online courses uk
online courses uk, Best course choice for your better future with distance learning ? online courses uk

 
online courses uk
online courses uk, Best course choice for your better future with distance learning ? online courses uk

 
เราคือผู้นำด้านเกมพนันออนไลน์ Major168 เราคือผู้ให้บริการ คาสิโนออนไลน์ คาสิโนออนไลน์ ที่ได้รับรองว่าดีที่สุดในประเทศไทย มีค่ายเกมส์ให้เล่นมากมาย Sagaming, Sexy bacarat, Dreamgame, Ebet, Wm casino, Vivo gaming ไม่ผ่านเอเย่นต์ ระบบปลอดภัยมีทีมงานดูแลตลอด 24ชม.

SAGAME88 แหล่งรวมเกมส์พนันออนไลน์ คาสิโนสด บาคาร่า กำถั่ว คาสิโนออนไลน์ ไฮโล รูเล็ต รับเครดิตฟรีเล่นได้ทุกเกมส์ โบนัสสมาชิกใหม่เพียบ พร้อมระบบฝากถอนออโต้ 10วิ เรามีทุกค่ายเกมส์ให้คุณเลือกเดิมพัน SA Game Sexy bacarat Dreamgame WM Casino VIVO Gaming Ebet เล่นได้ทุกเกมส์

Our website ufabet provides betting services in the system of Auto Deposit-Withdrawal. Our members are not only in Thailand. Online football betting UEFA Bet market And this makes a guarantee that Ufabet168 is another reliable football betting website

ufa through the website UFABET1688 a web gambling online , one that integrated all the bets from online casinos , online casino , online , and also have a game a lot more to be chosen to play such games.

 
We are providing the Assignment Academic help Freeassignmenthelp.com is a world-leading company in assignment Writing Services in The United kingdom and our Aim is 100% customer satisfaction.
Hello students, I am providing the Hnd assignment help service in the United kingdom. We provide the best assignment service because we aim for 100% student satisfaction.
case study analysis abstract assignment help
Hnd networking assignment
Assignment Of IT Security
free thesis assignment help
financial accounting analyst
HND Warehousing Management Assignment Help
HND Diploma in Web Design Assignment Help
HND Diploma in Digital marketing Assignment Help

 
Hey check this out helful blog christian singles dating app

 
Hey check this out helful blog christian singles dating app

 
Hey check this out helful blog christian singles dating app

 
Hey check this out helful blog christian singles app

 
Hey check this out helful blog christian singles app

 
Hey check this out helful blog christian singles app

 
Hey check this out helful blog christian singles app

 
Hey check this out helful blog christian singles app

 
Hey check this out helful blog christian singles app

 
Hey check this out helful blog christian singles dating app

 
Hey check this out helful blog christian singles dating app

 
Hey check this out helful blog christian singles dating app

 
Hey check this out helful blog christian singles dating app

 
Hey check this out helful blog christian singles dating app

 
Hey check this out helful blog christian singles app

 
Hey check this out helful blog christian singles app

 
this is great information. Thank you for sharing. team building baking class singapore
 
check out this great blog. team building activities singapore
 
Thanks for the information. Cooking Team Building Singapore
 
this is great information. Thank you for sharing. team building baking class singapore
 
Ethical HR
Ethical HR Hey check this out helpful blog, Amazingly compiled!

 
Ethical HR Consultancy
Ethical HR Consultancy Hey check this out helpful blog, Amazingly compiled!

 
Sustainable HR
Sustainable HR Hey check this out helpful blog, Amazingly compiled!

 
Sustainable HR Consultancy
Sustainable HR Consultancy Hey check this out helpful blog, Amazingly compiled!

 
vegan HR
vegan HR Hey check this out helpful blog, Amazingly compiled!

 
Ethical HR
Ethical HR Hey check this out helpful blog, Amazingly compiled!

 
Ethical HR Consultancy
Ethical HR Consultancy Hey check this out helpful blog, Amazingly compiled!

 
Sustainable HR
Sustainable HR Hey check this out helpful blog, Amazingly compiled!

 
Sustainable HR
Sustainable HR Hey check this out helpful blog, Amazingly compiled!

 
Sustainable HR Consultancy
Sustainable HR Consultancy Hey check this out helpful blog, Amazingly compiled!

 
vegan HR
vegan HR Hey check this out helpful blog, Amazingly compiled!

 
Vegan HR Consultancy
Vegan HR Consultancy Hey check this out helpful blog, Amazingly compiled!

 
Ethical HR
Ethical HR Hey check this out helpful blog, Amazingly compiled!

 
Ethical HR Consultancy
Ethical HR Consultancy Hey check this out helpful blog, Amazingly compiled!

 
Sustainable HR
Sustainable HR Hey check this out helpful blog, Amazingly compiled!

 
Sustainable HR Consultancy
Sustainable HR Consultancy Hey check this out helpful blog, Amazingly compiled!

 
vegan HR
vegan HR Hey check this out helpful blog, Amazingly compiled!

 
Vegan HR Consultancy
Vegan HR Consultancy Hey check this out helpful blog, Amazingly compiled!

 
Ethical HR
Ethical HR Hey check this out helpful blog, Amazingly compiled!

 
Ethical HR Consultancy
Ethical HR Consultancy Hey check this out helpful blog, Amazingly compiled!

 
Ethical HR Consultancy
Ethical HR Consultancy Hey check this out helpful blog, Amazingly compiled!

 
Ethical HR Consultancy
Ethical HR Consultancy Hey check this out helpful blog, Amazingly compiled!

 
Ethical HR Consultancy
Ethical HR Consultancy Hey check this out helpful blog, Amazingly compiled!

 
Sustainable HR
Sustainable HR Hey check this out helpful blog, Amazingly compiled!

 
oddbox
Hey check this out helpful blog,oddbox


 
Vegan HR Consultancy
Vegan HR Consultancy Hey check this out helpful blog, Amazingly compiled!

 
Ethical HR Consultancy
Ethical HR Consultancy Hey check this out helpful blog, Amazingly compiled!

 
Sustainable HR
Sustainable HR Hey check this out helpful blog, Amazingly compiled!

 
Your blog is filled with unique good articles! I was impressed how well you express your thoughts.

Bihar e Pass, serviceonline.bihar.gov.in epass status, Bihar e pass Apply Online 2021 - Online Registration

 
online liquor store
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat Online Liquor stores

 
california online liquor store
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat california online liquor store

 
buy alcohol online
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat! buy alcohol online

 
buy alcohol online
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat! buy alcohol online

 
cheap liquor
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat! cheap liquor

 
buy wine online
looking for a space where you can wet your thirsty throat buy wine online

 
«Oldest ‹Older 401 – 600 of 1505 Newer› Newest»

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]





<< Home












Sponsored by the Association for the Advancement of Artificial Intelligence. For more info: icwsm10@aaai.org